Matthew 12:38-42 meaning

The parallel Gospel accounts of Matthew 12:38-42 are Matthew 16:1-4, Mark 8:11-12 and Luke 11:29-32.

After Jesus tells the Pharisees that their hearts are evil, the scribes and Pharisees respond with yet another challenge to Him. This is the fourth and final challenge by the Pharisees in this chapter. In the organization of his gospel narrative, Matthew has used this chapter to reveal them as the primary earthly opposition to Christ and His ministry.

They called Jesus, Teacher. And while this is certainly a more respectable title than "Beelzebul" (Matthew 12:24), there is possibly a sarcastic and subtle belittlement in their choice of words. The Greek word that is translated, Teacher is "Didaskalos." It is a generic term for one who instructs others. In a general sense the scribes and Pharisees were also teachers ("Didaskaloi"). On one hand it might appear that they were including Jesus in their own social class or group, instead of looking down on Him. If they had been sincere, this might have been considered a positive development and elevation of their respect for Jesus than they had previously shown Him.

But they were not sincere. We know this because Jesus responds to them as an evil and adulterous generation (v 39). They were likely either being rudely sarcastic trying to amateurize Jesus as a wanna-be "didaskalos" instead of a professional rabbi, or perhaps they were adopting a new strategy to defeat Him.

The scribes and Pharisees said to Jesus, we want to see a sign from You (v 38). They were demanding that Jesus prove to them that He was the Messiah. There is a rich dramatic irony in their request. Jesus had already proved that He was the Messiah through His teachings and use of the scriptures, but also through His powerful miracles. In fact, He had just healed the man with a withered hand in their own synagogue (Matthew 12:9-14). If this was not enough of a sign for the scribes and Pharisees (v 38) to repent and follow Jesus as their Messiah, it's difficult to imagine what would convince them.

Their request was an "Either/Or" trap designed to establish control over Jesus. If Jesus cooperated with them and agreed to prove Himself on their terms, He would legitimize their authority over Him. But if Jesus refused to give them a sign, His failure to pass their test would be used against Him as powerful evidence that He was not the Messiah. Either way He answered, the scribes and Pharisees would win. As always, Jesus swatted aside their framing and replaced it with His own.

But Jesus knew the treachery in their hearts (John 2:24-25). He answered and said to them, An evil and adulterous generation craves for a sign (v 39). Jesus understood how they were trying to destroy or manipulate Him. He called them out for what they were: evil. He called them an adulterous generation. Jesus was charging them with spiritual adultery. Instead of being faithful to God, this generation of Jewish religious leaders had forsaken God to pursue the approval of other kingdoms (physical and spiritual) like so many Jewish generations before them (Jeremiah 3:8-10; Ezekiel 16:27-30; Hosea 4:11-12). Jesus also said that even as they were being spiritually adulterous, they still craved and feverishly sought after a sign from God. This was a bizarre testament to the fact they still recognized that they belonged to God and wished to be in a harmonious relationship with Him even as they were rejecting His great love.

After calling out the scribes and Pharisees' spiritual adultery, Jesus gave them His answer. It cleverly avoided both Either/Or and did not fit into their trap. He did not legitimize their authority by going along with their test and giving them a sign. But neither did He completely refuse them either. He rejected their framing and replaced it with His own. Instead, He said "and yet no sign will be given to it but the sign of Jonah the prophet" (v 39). In effect His answer was "I won't give you a sign proving Myself now, but one day I will." He did not tell them "yes" or "no," but "wait." And "wait" could not be easily used against Him.

Jesus's answer to them, the sign of Jonah the prophet (v 39), was also a prophetic riddle that could not easily be deciphered. Jonah was God's prophet sent to Israel's enemy: the city of Nineveh. He was to warn them that they were in divine peril because of their wickedness (Jonah 1:1-2; Jonah 3:4). Astonishingly, the city of Nineveh repented (Jonah 3:5). And because of their repentance, God did not destroy them (Jonah 3:10). In mentioning Jonah, Jesus brings to mind Nineveh's example for the scribes and Pharisees to follow. But more to the point, Jesus says that the only sign that He will give to them will be the "sign of Jonah" (v 39). This sign will be the clearest proof that Jesus is the Messiah.

Jesus went on to explain what He meant by the sign of Jonah. Before Jonah went to Nineveh, he tried to run from God's plan by boarding a ship headed in the opposite direction (Jonah 1:3). As he tried to escape, a great storm arose and Jonah knew that he was the cause of the storm (Jonah 1:4). He told the sailors to throw him overboard to calm the storm (Jonah 1:12). They did and the storm was calmed (Jonah 1:15). But instead of drowning, God sent a great fish to swallow Jonah, where he was kept alive for three days and three nights in its belly (Jonah 1:17). After the three days and three nights, the sea monster (v 40) spit Jonah out onto dry land (Jonah 2:10). And this time, Jonah obeyed God and went to prophesy to the men of Nineveh (Jonah 3:3). The scribes and Pharisees would have been familiar with this spectacular story of Jonah.

Jesus explained that just as Jonah was three days and three nights in the belly of the sea monster, so will the Son of Man (Jesus's term for Himself and Messianic reference from Daniel 7:13-14) be three days and three nights in the heart of the earth (v 40). These Pharisees would have understood Jesus's Messianic reference, but it is unlikely that they would have understood at this time what He meant by spending three days and nights in the heart of the earth (v 40). Jesus was cryptically telling them that the sign that He would give to them proving that He was the Messiah was His resurrection from the dead, which lasted for a period of three days. Jesus's resurrection is the sign of Jonah. In essence, Jesus told them, "You will know that I am the Messiah when I rise from the dead!" But they would not have understood what He meant by this statement, until after this remarkable event took place.

This is the second time Jesus has alluded to His own death as Messiah (Matthew 10:38), and it is the first time He foretold His resurrection.

Jesus contrasts the repentance and wonder from outsiders when they merely heard prophetic warnings or reports of God's splendor against the considerable obstinance and folly that this generation is showing (and will continue to show) even as they witness the greater wonders of God occurring among them. Jesus uses the men of Nineveh and the Queen of the South as exemplars.

Jesus says at the day of judgment, that the men of Nineveh will stand up with this unfaithful and unbelieving generation and condemn it (v 41). The reason they will condemn it is because the men of Nineveh repented merely at Jonah's preaching, when behold, Jesus, the Son of God who is something greater than Jonah is here to preach and work many wonders among you (v 41). And you, the present generation are not repenting. Jesus's rebuke is that even wicked Gentiles who were God's enemy repented when God sent them a mere prophet, but behold you religious leaders who know the law and are God's chosen people are not willing to accept God's Messiah (and God Himself) when He comes to you. Shame on you!

Jesus gives a similar rebuke with a different example. At the day of judgment, that the Queen of the South will rise up with this unfaithful and unbelieving generation and condemn it (v 42). The Queen of the South appears to be a reference for the wealthy Queen of Sheba who visited King Solomon when she heard reports of his famous wisdom (1 Kings 10:1-13). Sheba was located far away to the South either in Africa (modern day Ethiopia) or the southern area of Arabia (modern day Yemen). It was practically at the ends of the earth (v 42) from Israel. This Gentile woman will condemn this present generation of Jewish men for their foolishness. She traveled from the ends of the earth to seek the wisdom of the mortal King Solomon in order to learn from him (v 42). But behold something greater—the Messiah, God Himself, the source and fountain of all wisdom—is here among you and you are foolishly ignoring what He has to teach you. Shame on you!

 By referring to these two examples of Gentile responsiveness to the testimony of God, Jesus might also be prophesying of the blessing that will come to the Gentiles through the rejection of the Jews (Romans 11).