David allowed Abner to walk away in an attempt to build unity for his kingdom despite Joab’s strenuous objections.
In the midst of King David’s reign over Judah, Joab—who served as David’s military commander—reacts strongly to the news that David permitted Abner, the commander of Saul’s army, to depart. The text says: “Then Joab came to the king and said, ‘What have you done? Behold, Abner came to you; why then have you sent him away and he is already gone?’” (v.24). Joab’s words reveal how he despised the idea of showing mercy to Abner, the man once loyal to Saul. At this stage of history, around the early 10th century BC, King David ruled in Hebron, which is located about 19 miles south of Jerusalem in the hill country of Judah. This city served as David’s capital before he moved his throne to Jerusalem (2 Samuel 2:11). By allowing Abner to leave, David demonstrated a willingness to negotiate unity among the divided tribes of Israel.
Joab’s frustration can also be seen as rooted in personal motives. He might have suspected Abner’s intentions, or perhaps harbored a vendetta because Abner had killed Joab’s brother, Asahel, in battle (2 Samuel 2:22-23). When Joab asks, “What have you done?” (v.24), he is both questioning David’s decision-making and asserting that Abner poses a continued threat. Yet King David’s broader strategy, as the chosen leader of Israel and forefather to Jesus Christ in the New Testament (Matthew 1:1-6), included bringing together the people under one kingdom. This laid a groundwork for the eventual unification of Israel and foreshadowed a Messiah who would gather both Jew and Gentile.
Joab’s outburst underscores the tension in David’s court between vengeance and the hope of forging peace, between distrust of old enemies and a new era of cooperation for the nation under God’s covenant plan.
Set to dark mode
2 Samuel 3:24 meaning
In the midst of King David’s reign over Judah, Joab—who served as David’s military commander—reacts strongly to the news that David permitted Abner, the commander of Saul’s army, to depart. The text says: “Then Joab came to the king and said, ‘What have you done? Behold, Abner came to you; why then have you sent him away and he is already gone?’” (v.24). Joab’s words reveal how he despised the idea of showing mercy to Abner, the man once loyal to Saul. At this stage of history, around the early 10th century BC, King David ruled in Hebron, which is located about 19 miles south of Jerusalem in the hill country of Judah. This city served as David’s capital before he moved his throne to Jerusalem (2 Samuel 2:11). By allowing Abner to leave, David demonstrated a willingness to negotiate unity among the divided tribes of Israel.
Joab’s frustration can also be seen as rooted in personal motives. He might have suspected Abner’s intentions, or perhaps harbored a vendetta because Abner had killed Joab’s brother, Asahel, in battle (2 Samuel 2:22-23). When Joab asks, “What have you done?” (v.24), he is both questioning David’s decision-making and asserting that Abner poses a continued threat. Yet King David’s broader strategy, as the chosen leader of Israel and forefather to Jesus Christ in the New Testament (Matthew 1:1-6), included bringing together the people under one kingdom. This laid a groundwork for the eventual unification of Israel and foreshadowed a Messiah who would gather both Jew and Gentile.
Joab’s outburst underscores the tension in David’s court between vengeance and the hope of forging peace, between distrust of old enemies and a new era of cooperation for the nation under God’s covenant plan.