This single verse reveals the breakdown of community ties in pursuit of personal gain.
“…They cried to the sons of Dan, who turned around and said to Micah, ‘What is the matter with you, that you have assembled together?’” (Judges 18:23)
In this scene, the tribe of Dan has taken Micah’s idols and his priest, leaving Micah furious and determined to reclaim what he believes was stolen. The verse says, “…They cried to the sons of Dan…” highlighting how Micah and his men pursue and confront the Danites, only for the Danites to retort, “What is the matter with you, that you have assembled together?” As the story unfolds, it becomes clear that Micah is greatly outnumbered and lacks the power to force the Danites to return the idols. Rather than admit fault, the Danites challenge Micah with this question, showing their confidence in their own strength and their intent to keep the shrine items. This direct confrontation reveals the unraveling respect for covenant faithfulness in Israel during the chaotic time of the judges, where “everyone did what was right in his own eyes” (Judges 17:6).
Micah dwelled in the hill country of Ephraim, while Dan’s original territory lay in the southwestern area by the Philistine coast. Unable to secure that region, the Danites traveled north, “adopting idolatry and ambushing and slaying a peaceful people along the way” (Judges 18:27-29). Their migration took them to the city of Laish, later renamed Dan, near the headwaters of the Jordan River. This resettlement is attested by references indicating that “the territory of Dan was originally located in the south by the Philistine coast, but the tribe of Dan moved north to the region of the city called Dan”. The era of the judges, which ran roughly from 1370 to 1050 BC, was marked by frequent lapses into idolatry like the one highlighted here. Micah’s attempt to retrieve his household gods and the Danites’ audacious response both underscore the moral confusion that prevailed.
The tribe of Dan’s question, “…What is the matter with you…?,” further demonstrates the hardened attitudes of a people who had drifted from wholehearted obedience to the LORD. Instead of showing unity in worshiping the God of Israel, they arrogantly challenge Micah’s complaints, placing self-interest over covenant loyalty. Throughout the Book of Judges, we see that such compromised worship and disregard for others led to insecurity and division among the tribes. God’s perfect plan for Israel was for them to worship Him alone and protect one another, but here the Danites are willing to undermine a fellow Israelite’s property and devotion.
Set to dark mode
Judges 18:23 meaning
“…They cried to the sons of Dan, who turned around and said to Micah, ‘What is the matter with you, that you have assembled together?’” (Judges 18:23)
In this scene, the tribe of Dan has taken Micah’s idols and his priest, leaving Micah furious and determined to reclaim what he believes was stolen. The verse says, “…They cried to the sons of Dan…” highlighting how Micah and his men pursue and confront the Danites, only for the Danites to retort, “What is the matter with you, that you have assembled together?” As the story unfolds, it becomes clear that Micah is greatly outnumbered and lacks the power to force the Danites to return the idols. Rather than admit fault, the Danites challenge Micah with this question, showing their confidence in their own strength and their intent to keep the shrine items. This direct confrontation reveals the unraveling respect for covenant faithfulness in Israel during the chaotic time of the judges, where “everyone did what was right in his own eyes” (Judges 17:6).
Micah dwelled in the hill country of Ephraim, while Dan’s original territory lay in the southwestern area by the Philistine coast. Unable to secure that region, the Danites traveled north, “adopting idolatry and ambushing and slaying a peaceful people along the way” (Judges 18:27-29). Their migration took them to the city of Laish, later renamed Dan, near the headwaters of the Jordan River. This resettlement is attested by references indicating that “the territory of Dan was originally located in the south by the Philistine coast, but the tribe of Dan moved north to the region of the city called Dan”. The era of the judges, which ran roughly from 1370 to 1050 BC, was marked by frequent lapses into idolatry like the one highlighted here. Micah’s attempt to retrieve his household gods and the Danites’ audacious response both underscore the moral confusion that prevailed.
The tribe of Dan’s question, “…What is the matter with you…?,” further demonstrates the hardened attitudes of a people who had drifted from wholehearted obedience to the LORD. Instead of showing unity in worshiping the God of Israel, they arrogantly challenge Micah’s complaints, placing self-interest over covenant loyalty. Throughout the Book of Judges, we see that such compromised worship and disregard for others led to insecurity and division among the tribes. God’s perfect plan for Israel was for them to worship Him alone and protect one another, but here the Danites are willing to undermine a fellow Israelite’s property and devotion.